Emergency First Aid at Work vs First Aid at Work: Which Course Does My Workplace Need?

Choosing the right workplace first aid course can feel confusing, particularly when Emergency First Aid at Work (EFAW) and First Aid at Work (FAW) sound so similar. Crane Medical Care delivers workplace first aid training across Cheshire, Wirral, Liverpool, North Wales and the wider North West, supporting businesses in areas including Chester and Ellesmere Port.

Both qualifications are designed to prepare people to respond when somebody becomes ill or injured at work, but they provide different levels of training. The right option for your organisation will depend on a number of factors such as your workplace hazards, number of employees, working patterns and the types of incidents that could reasonably occur.

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) states that employers should use the findings of their first aid needs assessment to determine the appropriate level of training for their first aiders.

So, when comparing Emergency First Aid at Work vs First Aid at Work, what are the key differences and which course is right for your workplace?

Explore First Aid Training

• 

• 

• 

What is Emergency First Aid at Work?

Emergency First Aid at Work, commonly referred to as EFAW, is designed to provide essential first aid skills for responding to workplace emergencies.

According to HSE guidance, someone trained to EFAW level is qualified to provide emergency first aid to a person who becomes injured or ill at work.

It is often chosen by organisations whose first aid needs assessment identifies a requirement for trained first aiders but where the workplace presents a relatively lower level of risk.

An EFAW course typically focuses on the immediate actions a first aider may need to take while waiting for further medical help.

Training commonly develops practical skills around areas such as:

• Assessing an emergency situation

• Managing an unresponsive casualty

• Cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR)

• Using an automated external defibrillator (AED)

• Choking

• Seizures

• External bleeding

• Shock

• Minor injuries

  
  

The emphasis is very much on recognising an emergency, taking appropriate immediate action and helping keep the casualty safe until further assistance is available.

What is First Aid at Work?

First Aid at Work, usually shortened to FAW, provides a broader level of workplace first aid training.

HSE describes FAW-trained first aiders as being qualified to EFAW level while also being able to apply first aid to a wider range of specific injuries and illnesses.

For that reason, the course may be more appropriate for workplaces where the first aid needs assessment identifies greater hazards, more complex risks or the potential for a wider range of injuries and medical emergencies.

Alongside the core emergency skills covered within EFAW, First Aid at Work training can cover additional subjects such as:

• More detailed casualty assessment

• Injuries to bones, muscles and joints

• Head and spinal injuries

• Chest injuries

• Burns and scalds

• Eye injuries

• Poisoning

• Anaphylaxis

• Asthma

• Diabetes

• Heart attack

• Stroke

• Monitoring a casualty

• Providing an effective handover to further medical care

  
  

The broader course content gives workplace first aiders more time to develop practical skills and consider different situations they may encounter.

What is the main difference between EFAW and FAW?

The simplest way to understand the difference is that EFAW focuses on essential emergency first aid, while FAW provides those emergency skills plus training for a broader range of workplace injuries and illnesses.

That does not mean one course is automatically “better” than the other.

The correct course is the one that is appropriate for the needs and risks of your workplace.

A small office, for example, may have very different first aid requirements from a warehouse, manufacturing environment or organisation operating across several locations.

Choosing FAW simply because it contains more content may not always be necessary. Equally, choosing the shorter EFAW option purely for convenience may not provide sufficient training where the workplace has more significant risks.

The starting point should therefore always be your first aid needs assessment.

What should a workplace first aid needs assessment consider?

Employers are required to assess their first aid needs so they can determine what equipment, facilities and personnel should be available.

Employers should consider factors including:

• The type of work being carried out

• Workplace hazards and the likelihood of those hazards causing harm

• The size of the workforce

• Employee working patterns

• Holidays and other absences

• Previous accidents within the business

  
  

There may be other factors relevant to your organisation too.

For example, you may need to consider employees who work remotely, travel regularly, work alone, operate across several sites or work unusual shift patterns.

You should also think realistically about the types of injuries or illnesses your employees could experience.

An office environment may primarily involve relatively low-level workplace hazards, whereas a construction, industrial, warehouse or manufacturing environment could expose employees to machinery, vehicles, manual handling, tools or other higher-risk activities.

The outcome of this assessment should guide both the number of first aiders you need and the level of training they require. HSE makes clear that there are no universal fixed numbers that apply to every workplace; the circumstances of the individual organisation need to be considered.

When might Emergency First Aid at Work be appropriate?

EFAW may be suitable where a workplace first aid needs assessment identifies a requirement for an emergency first aider, and the range of likely incidents does not require the broader FAW syllabus.

Examples might include some:

• Offices

• Retail workplaces

• Small businesses

• Professional services environments

• Hospitality settings

• Community organisations

• Lower-risk workplaces

  
  

However, these examples should never be used as a substitute for your own assessment.

Two businesses operating in the same sector can have very different arrangements. Their workforce size, premises, equipment, opening hours, shift structure and accident history may all affect the level of first aid provision required.

The course should therefore be selected based on the organisation itself, rather than simply its industry label.

When might First Aid at Work be more suitable?

FAW may be more appropriate when the assessment identifies a wider or more significant range of potential workplace injuries and illnesses.

This could include organisations operating in environments such as:

• Warehousing and logistics

• Manufacturing

• Engineering

• Construction

• Larger workplaces

• Workplaces using machinery or specialist equipment

• Organisations with more complex operational risks

  
  

It may also be appropriate where employers want designated first aiders to have a broader range of practical skills because of the nature of the workforce or working environment.

Again, the decision should be based on the first aid needs assessment rather than assuming that every organisation within a particular industry requires the same qualification.

What if my workplace only needs an appointed person?

Not every workplace will necessarily need a trained first aider.

HSE explains that where a first aid needs assessment identifies that a trained first aider is not required, the minimum provision is an appointed person who takes responsibility for first aid arrangements. This includes looking after first aid equipment and facilities and calling the emergency services when required.

An appointed person is not the same as a trained first aider and should not provide first aid for which they have not been trained.

Even in a very small or lower-risk workplace, employers should therefore complete the assessment rather than simply assuming that no formal arrangements are necessary.

How many workplace first aiders do I need?

There is no single number that applies to every business. Employers should determine the number of first aiders they require using their first aid needs assessment and considering the circumstances of the workplace.

You should think about whether appropriate cover will remain available during:

• Holidays

• Sickness

• Breaks

• Different shifts

• Remote working

• Business travel

• Multiple-site working

  
  

For example, having one qualified first aider on paper may not provide adequate cover if that person frequently works away from the premises or is unavailable when other employees are working.

Planning should focus on reliable first aid provision during the times people are actually at work.

Do first aiders need refresher training?

Skills such as CPR and emergency assessment are practical skills, and confidence can reduce when they are not regularly used.

Annual refresher training is not a mandatory requirement, but it is strongly recommended to help first aiders maintain their basic skills and keep up to date with changes in first aid procedures.

Employers should therefore think beyond simply obtaining certificates.

Regular practical training can give first aiders opportunities to revisit important procedures, practise scenarios and identify areas where additional development may be useful.

Should first aid training be delivered at the workplace?

Workplace first aid training can be delivered either at a training venue or, where suitable, at the organisation's own premises. For businesses across Cheshire, Liverpool, Wirral, Chester and Ellesmere Port, arranging first aid training at the workplace can reduce employee travel and make it easier to train several team members together.

On-site training can be particularly useful for businesses that need to train several employees at the same time.

It can reduce travel and make organising attendance easier while allowing discussions and scenarios to feel more relevant to the learners' working environment.

For organisations with specific risks, bespoke first aid training can also complement formal qualifications by focusing on incidents that employees may realistically encounter.

It is important, however, to distinguish additional bespoke training from regulated EFAW or FAW qualifications. Where a recognised qualification is required, the required course content and assessment must still be completed.

Choosing a first aid training provider

The course itself is only part of the decision. Employers should also be satisfied that the organisation delivering their workplace first aid training is competent.

When considering a provider, it is sensible to look at areas such as:

• Trainer competence and experience

• Course quality assurance

• Appropriate practical equipment

• Assessment arrangements

• Qualification and certification processes

• The relevance of training to the workplace

• Opportunities for learners to practise practical skills

  
  

Training should give employees more than theoretical knowledge. A workplace first aider may eventually need to use these skills in a stressful and unexpected situation, so practical confidence matters.

Emergency First Aid at Work vs First Aid at Work: which course should you choose?

There is no universal answer.

Emergency First Aid at Work may be appropriate where the organisation's first aid needs assessment identifies a requirement for essential emergency first aid skills. First Aid at Work provides a broader level of training and may be more suitable where workplace hazards or likely incidents require additional capability.

The key questions to ask are:

• What hazards exist within our workplace?

• What injuries or illnesses could reasonably occur?

• How many people work here?

• Do we operate shifts?

• Are first aiders available whenever employees are working?

• Do employees travel, work remotely or work alone?

• What does our accident history tell us?

• Would EFAW provide sufficient capability for the risks identified?

• Would the broader FAW qualification be more appropriate?

  
  

If you are unsure, reviewing these factors with an experienced first aid training provider, like Crane Medical Care, can help you make a more informed decision.

First Aid Training Across the North West

Crane Medical Care provides practical workplace first aid training for businesses and organisations across Cheshire, Wirral, Liverpool, North Wales and the wider North West, including training for teams in areas such as Chester and Ellesmere Port.

Courses include Emergency First Aid at Work, Three-Day First Aid at Work, First Aid Refresher Courses and Bespoke First Aid Training, with delivery available at suitable client premises.

Our training focuses on practical participation, realistic scenarios and helping learners build the confidence to respond effectively when somebody becomes ill or injured.

Need Help Choosing the Right First Aid Course?

If you are unsure whether your workplace requires Emergency First Aid at Work or First Aid at Work training, start with your first aid needs assessment.

Once you understand the risks and requirements within your organisation, the right training option becomes much easier to identify.

Crane Medical Care can discuss your workplace, team and training requirements and help you select a suitable course.

Speak to our training team to discuss first aid training for your workplace.

Speak to Our Training Team